How long does an insurance company have to pay an IDR award?
30 calendar days from the determination. When the certified IDR entity picks the provider's offer, the insurance company must pay the difference between that offer and what it already paid within 30 days (45 CFR 149.510). The award is binding on both sides. Day 31 with no payment means the insurance company is out of compliance with federal law.
How common is non-payment?
Common enough that physician groups track it. In a 2024 survey by the Emergency Department Practice Management Association, reported by HFMA, nearly a quarter of respondents said they had not been paid the IDR amount owed within the statutory deadline. Insurer groups have disputed the reliability of surveys like this one.
What can I do when an award goes unpaid?
The law's main enforcement route is a complaint to regulators. The federal No Surprises Help Desk takes complaints about insurance companies that don't pay IDR awards (cms.gov/nosurprises) and routes them to the right agency.
In practice, collecting takes more than a complaint. It takes tracking every due date and keeping a clean record of every award. That's the work MD Claims does on every award we file.
Can I sue to enforce an IDR award?
It depends on where you are, and the trend is against it. Two federal appeals courts have held that the No Surprises Act gives providers no private right to sue to collect an award:
- Fifth Circuit (Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi): Guardian Flight v. Health Care Service Corp. (2025). The Supreme Court declined to review it in January 2026.
- Second Circuit (New York, Connecticut, Vermont): East Coast Advanced Plastic Surgery v. Cigna (September 17, 2026).
A federal district court in Maryland went the other way in March 2026 (PHI Health v. Optimum Choice). Two federal judges in Illinois sided with the insurer, and those cases are now on appeal in the Seventh Circuit. Most of the country has no appellate ruling yet. State-law claims are being tested too, with mixed results. MD Claims is not a law firm. Ask counsel what is available where you practice. Our posts on where the courts stand and the Second Circuit ruling have the detail.
Is Congress doing anything about unpaid awards?
There is a bill, and it has the broadest support of any IDR reform. The bipartisan No Surprises Enforcement Act (H.R. 4710) would penalize insurance companies that miss the 30-day deadline. It hasn't passed. A competing proposal, the Lower Premiums, Faster Payments Act, would end IDR for services furnished from 2028 on (our summary). Neither changes the awards you hold today.
Can I get paid now instead of waiting?
Yes. MD Claims can advance capital against IDR awards the insurance company hasn't paid. You have already won, so the question is when the insurance company pays, not whether. We price the award on that basis, put the offer in writing and wire the funds. It is not a loan: no interest, no personal guarantee and no lien on the practice. See money today for how the advance works.
How does MD Claims help with unpaid awards?
- We follow every award we file through to payment.
- We can advance against awards that are still unpaid, so a slow insurance company doesn't decide when you get your money.
- We file the next batch so a slow payer doesn't decide whether you keep using IDR. See IDR filing services.
Related
General information, not legal advice. MD Claims is not a law firm. Talk to counsel about your specific situation.