Short, sourced answers to the questions providers and practice administrators ask most about the No Surprises Act and federal Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR). For the full walkthrough, read our guide to the No Surprises Act for providers.
MD Claims is not a law firm, and nothing on this page is legal advice.
What is the No Surprises Act?
The No Surprises Act is a federal law that stops surprise out-of-network bills to patients and sends the payment dispute between the provider and the insurance company to arbitration. Congress passed it in December 2020 as part of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021. Its main protections took effect on January 1, 2022. For providers, the key change is federal IDR, the process that replaced balance billing.
Which services does the No Surprises Act cover?
Out-of-network emergency care, non-emergency care by out-of-network providers at in-network facilities, and air ambulance. The second group covers hospital-based specialties such as emergency medicine, anesthesiology, radiology, pathology and laboratory, neonatology, hospitalists, intensivists and assistant surgeons. Ground ambulance is not covered. More on coverage.
Does the No Surprises Act apply to Medicare or Medicaid?
No. It applies to private health coverage, not to Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE, the VA or the Indian Health Service. Those programs have their own billing rules. Fully insured plans, self-funded employer plans and the Federal Employees Health Benefits program are covered.
When you say "insurance company," does that include self-funded employer plans?
Yes. On this site, "insurance company" means whoever pays the claim. That includes health insurers, self-funded employer plans, union and other multiemployer plans, and the third-party administrators (TPAs) that process claims for them. Many plans that look like insurance are self-funded, with the insurer acting only as administrator. Federal IDR covers all of them.
Can I bill the patient for the balance?
No. When the law applies, you can't bill the patient more than their in-network cost sharing. The rest of the payment is between you and the insurance company. The patient's protections for ancillary services, such as anesthesiology and radiology, can't be waived.
Does a state surprise-billing law apply instead of federal IDR?
Sometimes. Where a state has its own surprise-billing law, fully insured plans in that state often use the state process instead. Self-funded employer plans are generally governed by federal law, so their disputes usually go to federal IDR. Which process applies is one of the first things to check on any claim.
What is federal IDR?
Federal IDR is "baseball-style" arbitration: the provider and the insurance company each submit one offer, and a certified IDR entity picks one of them in full. There is no splitting the difference. As of September 2026, CMS had certified 17 IDR entities.
How do I start a No Surprises Act payment dispute?
Send a notice to start open negotiation within 30 business days of the insurance company's initial payment or denial. The parties then have 30 business days to agree. If they don't, either side can start federal IDR within 4 business days after negotiation ends. See how MD Claims runs a dispute.
What are the federal IDR deadlines?
The main deadlines are 30 business days to open negotiation, 30 business days of negotiation, then 4 business days to start IDR. After that, the parties have 3 business days to agree on an IDR entity, and offers are due within 10 business days of its selection. The entity has 30 business days to decide, and the losing side has 30 calendar days to pay. Missing a deadline can make a claim ineligible. The full table is in our provider guide.
How long does federal IDR take?
Expect several months from the first payment to cash, sometimes longer. The rules set the clock, but backlogs, eligibility objections and late payment often stretch it. If you'd rather not wait, see money today.
What is the qualifying payment amount (QPA)?
The QPA is the insurance company's own calculation of its median in-network rate for the same or a similar service in the same region, based on 2019 rates and adjusted for inflation. It sets the patient's cost sharing, and initial payments often land at or near it. The IDR entity must consider the QPA, but it isn't the answer by default.
Did the courts change how the QPA is calculated?
Yes. In August 2026 the full Fifth Circuit struck down two parts of the federal QPA rules, including the use of "ghost rates" for services a provider never actually furnishes. Commentators expect some QPAs to rise as a result. The government has asked the Supreme Court to review only the remedy, not the QPA ruling itself. Federal enforcement relief for the old method covered services furnished before October 1, 2026. Our summary.
What can the arbitrator consider besides the QPA?
The provider's training, experience, quality and outcomes, the market share of each side, patient acuity and complexity, the facility's teaching status and case mix, and good-faith efforts to contract. Contracted rates from the previous four years count too. The arbitrator may not consider billed charges, usual and customary charges, or Medicare and Medicaid rates.
What is batching?
Batching groups similar claims against the same insurance company into one dispute, which cuts fees. For disputes whose open negotiation begins on or after November 1, 2026, a batch can hold up to 50 line items under the new grouping rules. What changed on November 1.
What is the cooling-off period?
After an IDR decision, the party that started the dispute must wait before bringing the same service against the same opponent again. The wait is 90 calendar days for single and bundled disputes. For batched disputes whose open negotiation began on or after November 1, 2026, it is 30 business days. Claims from the waiting period can still be filed afterward.
What does federal IDR cost?
Each party pays a federal administrative fee per dispute, plus the IDR entity's fee. The administrative fee fell from $115 to $15 per party for disputes started on or after June 11, 2026 (CMS). The winning side's IDR entity fee is refunded, and the losing side's is kept. Entity fees vary by entity and by whether the dispute is batched.
Do providers win federal IDR?
Most of the time. Providers won 88% of disputes in the first half of 2025, up from 85% in 2024, according to a Georgetown University Center on Health Insurance Reforms analysis of CMS data. More than 4.8 million disputes had been filed through the end of 2025. Results still depend on filing eligible claims and setting a defensible offer.
Can the insurance company say a claim isn't eligible?
Yes, and eligibility objections are where many disputes are won or lost. Common grounds are a state law applying instead, coverage the law doesn't reach, a missed deadline, or a batch that breaks the rules. Under the 2026 IDR operations rule, objections come earlier and in writing.
What is the IDR Gateway?
The IDR Gateway is CMS's new online system for federal IDR, replacing the old single-use web forms. According to CMS's October 14 notice, Gateway account holders can submit web forms there beginning November 13, 2026. Most of the old web forms outside the Gateway end after January 15, 2027.
How long does the insurance company have to pay an IDR award?
30 calendar days from the determination. The award is binding on both sides (45 CFR 149.510). Day 31 without payment means the insurance company is out of compliance with federal law.
What if the insurance company doesn't pay the award?
The law's main enforcement route is a complaint to the federal No Surprises Help Desk (cms.gov/nosurprises). In practice, collecting also takes tracking every due date and keeping a clean record of every award. MD Claims does that on every award we file. What to do about an unpaid award.
Can I sue to collect an unpaid IDR award?
Not in every part of the country, and the law is still unsettled. The Fifth Circuit (2025) and the Second Circuit (September 2026) have held that providers can't sue under the Act to collect an award. A federal court in Maryland has allowed a collection suit, and the Seventh Circuit is now considering the question. Where the courts stand.
Is federal IDR going away?
Not today. In October 2026, Rep. Frank Pallone Jr. introduced the Lower Premiums, Faster Payments Act, which would end IDR for services furnished on or after January 1, 2028. It is a bill, not law, and as drafted, earlier services keep their IDR rights. Our summary of the bill.
What does MD Claims do?
MD Claims files and manages federal No Surprises Act IDR disputes for physicians, health systems and staffing companies, and can advance capital against claims already in arbitration, or awarded but not yet paid by insurance. We handle each dispute from the first open-negotiation notice until the award is paid. See IDR filing services.
Is MD Claims the same company as MD Claim or MD Claims Group?
No. MD Claims (mdclaims.co) is not affiliated with "MD Claim" medical billing software or with "MD Claims Group" property-insurance adjusters. Our only website is mdclaims.co. The domains md-claims.com, mdclaims.net and mdclaims.us are ours too, and they redirect to it.
What does it cost to file IDR with MD Claims?
There are no fees upfront. We are paid out of what we recover for you. That means we have no reason to file a claim that can't win. Terms are set against your portfolio and put in writing before you commit to anything.
Do we need a law firm to file IDR?
No. Federal IDR is an administrative process, not litigation, and you don't need a lawyer to file or to win. MD Claims is not a law firm and doesn't give legal advice. Where you already use counsel, we work alongside them.
We already have a billing company. Can we still work with you?
Yes. Your billing company keeps its workflow, and nothing about your revenue cycle has to change. We handle the IDR work alongside it.
Can I get paid now instead of waiting for the arbitrator?
Yes. MD Claims can advance capital against claims already in arbitration, or awarded but not yet paid by insurance. The amount depends on the claims themselves, and we put the number in writing before you commit to anything. See money today.
Is the advance a loan?
No. There is no interest, no personal guarantee and no lien on your practice. The advance doesn't appear as debt, and it doesn't encumber your other receivables.
What happens if the insurance company's offer wins?
You keep the advance and owe nothing back. That outcome risk moves to MD Claims when the advance closes.
Do I keep the initial payment the insurance company already made?
Yes, in all cases. The initial payment is yours and is never part of the advance. We look only at the disputed amount above it.
Do I have to take an advance to file with MD Claims?
No. The advance is optional, claim by claim. Take it on every claim, some of them or none. Filing with us never requires it, and it doesn't change how a case is run.
How does MD Claims handle patient information?
Don't send protected health information through our website forms or in a first email. We don't need it to tell you whether your claims are a fit. When we work with a client and need patient information to file, we receive it under a written client agreement and, where HIPAA requires, a business associate agreement. See our privacy policy.
How do I get started?
Send us a description of your out-of-network claims, without patient details, and we'll tell you which ones qualify and what they could be worth. Telling you what qualifies is the first thing we do, and it costs nothing.
Related
General information, not legal advice. MD Claims is not a law firm. Talk to counsel about your specific situation.