Courts

Second Circuit joins the Fifth: no federal lawsuit to collect an unpaid IDR award

By MD Claims ·

The Second Circuit held on September 17, 2026 that providers cannot sue under the No Surprises Act to collect an unpaid IDR award, joining the Fifth Circuit. Here is where that leaves providers holding awards the insurance company has not paid.

What the court decided

A plastic surgery practice won more than $3 million in IDR awards against Cigna, according to the opinion, and Cigna didn't pay them. The practice sued in federal court in Manhattan, asking for a declaration that the money was owed. The district court dismissed the case, and on September 17, 2026 the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit affirmed (East Coast Advanced Plastic Surgery v. Cigna, No. 25-2204).

The holding is short: the No Surprises Act gives providers a right to be paid an IDR award, but it gives enforcement of that right to federal agencies and the states, not to providers in court. So a provider can't sue under the Act to collect an unpaid award. The court also held that the federal Declaratory Judgment Act doesn't fill the gap, because it creates no claim of its own.

How it differs from the Fifth Circuit

The Fifth Circuit reached the same result in Guardian Flight v. Health Care Service Corp. (2025), and the Supreme Court declined to review that case in January 2026. Part of the Fifth Circuit's reasoning was that suing to enforce an award is a form of "judicial review," which the Act largely bars.

The Second Circuit did not decide that point. It assumed the review bar might not block a collection suit, and ruled for Cigna anyway because nothing in the Act shows Congress meant to create a private lawsuit. The route is different but the result is the same: in both circuits, the courthouse door is closed to an Act-based collection suit.

Where the law stands now

  • No federal collection suit under the Act: the Fifth Circuit (Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi) and now the Second Circuit (New York, Connecticut, Vermont).
  • Connecticut's earlier provider win is under pressure. A federal judge in Connecticut ruled in 2025 that air ambulance providers could sue Aetna and Cigna to collect IDR awards. That court sits inside the Second Circuit, and Cigna filed a brief on September 28 arguing the new ruling controls.
  • Maryland still points the other way. The district court in PHI Health v. Optimum Choice (March 2026) allowed a collection suit. It sits in the Fourth Circuit, which hasn't ruled.
  • Everywhere else, the question is open. No other appeals court has decided it. A ruling for providers in another circuit would create the split that usually brings the Supreme Court in.

Troutman Pepper Locke expects providers to try state-law claims instead, and notes that some federal courts have already held that those claims fail too, because they would let providers do indirectly what the Act doesn't allow. Expect that to be decided state by state.

What it means for providers

  • The award is still binding. The ruling is about how you collect, not whether you're owed. The insurance company still has 30 days to pay.
  • Plan for the administrative route. In the Second and Fifth Circuits, the realistic path is a complaint to the regulators through CMS's No Surprises Help Desk.
  • Documentation is your leverage. Keep the determination, the 30-day due date and every follow-up. Regulators act on a clean record.
  • Congress is the other lever. The bipartisan No Surprises Enforcement Act (H.R. 4710) would penalize insurers that miss the 30-day deadline. This ruling strengthens the argument for it, and award enforcement is the reform with the broadest support in the current debate.

For the full background, including the Supreme Court's denial in Guardian Flight and the Anthem v. HaloMD appeal, see our earlier post on where the courts stand on unpaid IDR awards.

MD Claims is not a law firm, and this post is not legal advice. Whether any lawsuit is available to you depends on where you are and on your facts; ask counsel.

Holding an award the insurance company hasn't paid? MD Claims follows every award through to payment, and can advance capital against IDR awards that are still unpaid.

What law firms are saying

Sources

More news

This is news and commentary, not legal advice. Talk to counsel about your specific situation.