What is the No Surprises Act?
The No Surprises Act is a federal law that protects patients from surprise out-of-network bills and sends the payment dispute between the provider and the insurance company to arbitration. Congress passed it in December 2020 as part of the Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021, and its main protections took effect on January 1, 2022. For providers, the patient-billing rules matter less than what replaced balance billing: the federal Independent Dispute Resolution (IDR) process.
In short: when the law applies, you can't bill the patient more than their in-network cost sharing. The insurance company pays you an initial amount. If you think that amount is too low, you negotiate, and if negotiation fails, an arbitrator decides.
Which services does the No Surprises Act cover?
Three kinds of out-of-network care:
- Emergency services, at hospital emergency departments and freestanding emergency departments, including care after the patient is stabilized unless the patient gives valid notice and consent.
- Non-emergency services by out-of-network providers at in-network facilities. This is where hospital-based specialties come in. For ancillary services (emergency medicine, anesthesiology, pathology, radiology, neonatology, assistant surgeons, hospitalists, intensivists and diagnostic services including laboratory), the patient's protections cannot be waived.
- Air ambulance services. Ground ambulance is not covered.
The law applies to private health coverage: fully insured plans, self-funded employer plans and the Federal Employees Health Benefits program. It does not apply to Medicare, Medicaid, TRICARE, the VA or the Indian Health Service, which have their own billing rules.
What can providers do if an insurance company pays too little?
Start open negotiation, then federal IDR. The insurance company must send an initial payment or a notice of denial within 30 calendar days of receiving a clean claim. If the payment is too low, you have 30 business days from receiving it to start open negotiation. If you can't agree within the 30-business-day negotiation period, either side can start IDR.
How does federal IDR work, step by step?
Federal IDR is "baseball-style" arbitration: each side submits one offer, and a certified IDR entity (the arbitrator) picks one of them in full, with no splitting the difference.
| Step | What happens | Deadline |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Initial payment | The insurance company pays or denies the claim | 30 calendar days after the clean claim |
| 2. Open negotiation | Either party sends a notice to negotiate | Within 30 business days of the initial payment or denial |
| 3. Negotiation period | The parties try to agree on a payment | 30 business days |
| 4. Start IDR | Either party initiates federal IDR | Within 4 business days after negotiation ends |
| 5. Pick the arbitrator | The parties agree on a certified IDR entity, or the government assigns one | 3 business days to agree |
| 6. Submit offers | Each side submits its final offer and supporting information | Within 10 business days of selection |
| 7. Determination | The arbitrator picks one offer | Within 30 business days of selection |
| 8. Payment | The losing side pays any amount owed | Within 30 calendar days of the determination |
Two more rules shape strategy. Batching lets you group similar claims against the same insurance company into one dispute, which cuts fees. The cooling-off period means that after a determination, the party that started the dispute can't bring the same service against the same opponent to IDR for 90 calendar days. Claims from that window can be filed in the 30 business days after it ends.
What is the qualifying payment amount (QPA)?
The QPA is the insurance company's median contracted rate for the same or a similar service, in the same specialty and geographic region, as of January 31, 2019, increased for inflation each year. It sets the patient's cost sharing, and initial payments often land at or near it. For many providers, that is well below what the service was paid before the law.
The way insurance companies calculate the QPA is changing. In August 2026, the full Fifth Circuit struck down parts of the federal QPA rules, including counting rates for services a provider never performs and excluding bonus and incentive payments. Commentators expect some QPAs to rise as insurers recalculate. More on the ruling.
In IDR, the arbitrator must consider the QPA, but it isn't the answer by default. Provider lawsuits led by the Texas Medical Association led federal courts to strike down rules that told arbitrators to give the QPA extra weight. Arbitrators now weigh it alongside the other factors in the statute:
- the provider's training, experience, quality and outcomes;
- the market share of the provider and the insurance company;
- the acuity of the patient and the complexity of the service;
- the facility's teaching status, case mix and scope of services; and
- good-faith efforts, or the lack of them, to agree on network rates, and contracted rates over the previous four years.
Arbitrators may not consider the provider's billed charges, usual and customary charges, or Medicare and Medicaid rates.
Which claims are eligible for federal IDR?
A claim generally qualifies when all of these are true:
- It's one of the covered services above, provided out of network.
- The patient has private coverage the law applies to, not Medicare, Medicaid or another public program.
- No state surprise-billing law applies instead. Fully insured plans in states with their own law often use the state process. Self-funded employer plans usually use federal IDR.
- Open negotiation was started and completed on time, and IDR was started within 4 business days after it ended.
- It's not blocked by a cooling-off period, and any batch meets the batching rules.
Eligibility is where many disputes are won or lost. Insurance companies routinely object that claims are ineligible, and under the 2026 rule those objections come earlier and in writing.
What does federal IDR cost?
There are two costs. Each party pays a federal administrative fee for each dispute, which fell from $115 to $15 for disputes started on or after June 11, 2026. Each party also pays the certified IDR entity's fee upfront. The losing side's fee is kept and the winning side's fee is refunded. IDR entity fees vary by entity and by whether the dispute is batched.
Do providers win federal IDR?
Most of the time. Providers won 88% of disputes in the first half of 2025, up from 85% in 2024, according to a Georgetown University Center on Health Insurance Reforms analysis of CMS data. More than 4.8 million disputes had been filed through the end of 2025, far more than regulators expected. Insurers and employers argue the process is being overused, which is part of why Congress is considering changes.
What changed in 2026?
The federal IDR operations rule, finalized in late May 2026, changed how the process runs. It didn't change who is covered. (The QPA calculation is changing separately, because of a court ruling. See above.)
- The administrative fee fell to $15 per party.
- Batches can hold 50 items instead of 25.
- Open negotiation moves into the federal portal.
- Insurance companies must state ineligibility reasons up front.
- Objections are due within 3 business days, and eligibility decisions within 5.
Details are in our summary of the rule.
What happens if the insurance company doesn't pay the award?
The law requires payment within 30 calendar days of the determination, but it doesn't say how a provider collects when the insurance company misses that deadline. Two federal appeals courts, the Fifth Circuit in 2025 and the Second Circuit in September 2026, have held that providers can't sue under the Act to collect an unpaid award, and the Supreme Court declined to review the Fifth Circuit's decision in January 2026. A federal court in Maryland has allowed a collection suit, so the question is still open in other parts of the country, and the Seventh Circuit is now considering it after two Illinois rulings against providers. The practical route today is a complaint to CMS's No Surprises Help Desk. More on where the courts stand.
Is federal IDR going away?
Not today. In October 2026, Rep. Frank Pallone Jr. announced the Lower Premiums, Faster Payments Act, which would end IDR for services furnished on or after January 1, 2028 and pay the QPA within 30 days instead. It's a proposal, not law, and analysts give it limited near-term odds. As drafted, earlier services keep their IDR rights. Narrower fixes, such as enforcing payment of awards, have broader support. Our summary of the bill.
How MD Claims helps
MD Claims files and manages federal IDR disputes end to end, with no fees upfront. We screen eligibility, work the deadlines, build the case, set the offer and follow every award to payment. And if you would rather not wait several months, we can give you money today for claims already in arbitration, or awarded but not yet paid.
Sources: the No Surprises Act and its regulations, including 45 CFR 149.510; CMS No Surprises Act resources; and the Georgetown CHIR analysis of 2025 IDR data.
Related
- No Surprises Act IDR filing services
- Money today for claims in arbitration or awarded but unpaid
- The 2026 IDR operations rule: $15 fees, 50-item batches and tighter deadlines
- Pallone bill would end IDR for services after 2027
- Insurer hasn't paid your IDR award? Where the courts stand
- Second Circuit joins the Fifth: no federal lawsuit to collect an unpaid IDR award
General information, not legal advice. MD Claims is not a law firm. Talk to counsel about your specific situation.