Courts
Insurer hasn't paid your IDR award? Where the courts stand on enforcement
The No Surprises Act gives insurers 30 days to pay an IDR award, but it doesn't say how a provider collects when they don't. Two appeals courts now say providers can't sue, the Supreme Court declined to step in, and Congress hasn't acted. Here is where things stand.
The gap in the law
When an IDR entity picks the provider's offer, the insurer must pay within 30 days. The statute doesn't say what happens if it doesn't. Physician groups say late and missing payments are common: a 2024 EDPMA survey, reported by HFMA, found nearly a quarter of respondents had not been paid the IDR amount owed within the statutory timeframe.
Two appeals courts: no lawsuit to enforce
In Guardian Flight v. Health Care Service Corp. (June 12, 2025), two air ambulance companies sued over awards that weren't paid on time. The Fifth Circuit held the No Surprises Act creates no private right of action to enforce an IDR award. Its reasoning: the statute bars judicial review of awards outside narrow arbitration-law grounds, and suing to enforce an award is itself a form of review.
The providers asked the Supreme Court to take the case. It declined on January 12, 2026 (No. 25-441). The Fifth Circuit ruling binds federal courts in Texas, Louisiana and Mississippi.
The Second Circuit has since sided with the Fifth. In East Coast Advanced Plastic Surgery v. Cigna (September 17, 2026), a practice holding more than $3 million in unpaid awards sued to collect. The court held that the Act gives providers a right to be paid but leaves enforcement to federal and state regulators, so there is no private lawsuit to collect. That rule now covers New York, Connecticut and Vermont too. The court took a different route than the Fifth Circuit and didn't decide whether every kind of enforcement proceeding is barred. Our full summary of the ruling.
Other courts: yes, you can
Not every court agrees, though the ground is shifting.
- Connecticut (2025). A federal district court ruled for air ambulance companies seeking about $20 million in IDR payments from Aetna and Cigna. It found the law's text and structure support judicial enforcement. The insurers did not appeal. That court sits inside the Second Circuit, whose September 2026 ruling now points the other way, and Cigna has asked the court to apply it.
- Maryland (March 27, 2026). In PHI Health v. Optimum Choice, a federal court refused to dismiss an air ambulance provider's suit. It held that a binding IDR award left unpaid after 30 days can be enforced in court and turned into a judgment, and it expressly declined to follow the Fifth Circuit.
No other federal appeals court has ruled. A provider-friendly decision in another circuit would create a true split and give the Supreme Court a reason to take the issue.
The Seventh Circuit is next. Two federal judges in Chicago dismissed provider collection suits against HCSC in 2026, and five appeals are now consolidated there (SpecialtyCare v. HCSC, No. 26-2269), with the AMA supporting the providers. State-law claims haven't fared better: in September a New York state court dismissed a practice's state-law suit over $1.7 million in unpaid awards. Our summary.
Insurers attacking awards haven't fared well either
Insurers have also sued to undo awards. In Anthem Blue Cross v. HaloMD, a federal court in California dismissed all of Anthem's claims without leave to amend on April 9, 2026. It held that IDR determinations are binding except on narrow grounds, and that eligibility objections belong inside the IDR process, not in a later lawsuit. Anthem has appealed to the Ninth Circuit. For providers, the upshot is that a well-documented award is hard to unwind. The fight is over getting it paid.
Congress
The bipartisan No Surprises Enforcement Act (H.R. 4710, 119th Congress) would penalize insurers that miss the 30-day deadline: three times the difference between the initial payment and the award. It hasn't advanced. Award enforcement is also the reform with the broadest support in the current debate over the Pallone bill.
What providers can do today
- Document everything: the determination, the due date, every follow-up.
- File a complaint with CMS. The No Surprises Help Desk (1-800-985-3059, or online at cms.gov/nosurprises) takes complaints about insurers that don't comply, and CMS can investigate and pursue penalties against them.
- Outside the Fifth and Second Circuits, ask counsel about court. In Texas, Louisiana, Mississippi, New York, Connecticut and Vermont, a federal suit under the Act is effectively closed. Elsewhere it depends on where you are and is unsettled law.
MD Claims follows every award through to payment. Already won and still waiting? We can advance capital against IDR awards the insurance company hasn't paid yet, as well as against claims still in arbitration.
What law firms are saying
- Hall Render: Fifth Circuit Holds There Is No Private Right of Action Under the No Surprises Act
- Husch Blackwell: No Surprises, New Challenges — Supreme Court Limits Provider Enforcement Under NSA
- Crowell & Moring: Not So Surprising — The Fifth Circuit Finds No Private Right of Action in the No Surprises Act
- Troutman Pepper Locke: Second Circuit Deals Major Blow to Providers Seeking to Enforce IDR Awards Through Private Lawsuits
- Leech Tishman: A Win for Providers in No Surprises Act IDR Litigation
Sources
- Guardian Flight v. HCSC — Fifth Circuit holds no private right of action (summary by Hall Render)
- No Surprises Act IDR enforcement uncertain after Supreme Court declines review (HFMA)
- East Coast Advanced Plastic Surgery v. Cigna, No. 25-2204 (2d Cir. Sept. 17, 2026)
- PHI Health, LLC v. Optimum Choice, Inc., No. 25-cv-2320 (D. Md. Mar. 27, 2026), memorandum opinion
- Georgetown O'Neill Institute — No Surprises Act litigation tracker
More news
This is news and commentary, not legal advice. Talk to counsel about your specific situation.