Regulations, legislation, court rulings and law-firm analysis, explained for the
practices, health systems and staffing companies with claims in federal IDR.
In August the full Fifth Circuit struck down two parts of the federal rules for calculating the qualifying payment amount (QPA), a change commentators expect to push some QPAs up. On October 14 the government asked the Supreme Court to review only the remedy, not the QPA holding itself.
Two federal judges in Chicago held this year that providers can't sue to collect unpaid IDR awards. Five appeals are now consolidated in the Seventh Circuit, backed by the AMA. Separately, PHI Health has sued Anthem in at least three states, alleging roughly $30 million in unpaid awards nationwide.
CMS called in the leaders of all 17 certified IDR entities on October 1, Rep. Pallone has demanded records from six of them, and on October 19 a STAT investigation looked at how much money some of the nonprofit ones are making. Here is what the scrutiny means for disputes you file now.
The batching rules in the 2026 IDR operations rule apply to disputes whose open negotiation begins on or after November 1, 2026: up to 50 line items per batch, new grouping rules and a 30-business-day cooling-off period. Most other changes are still waiting on CMS, and the new IDR Gateway takes over the web forms from November 13.
The Second Circuit held on September 17, 2026 that providers cannot sue under the No Surprises Act to collect an unpaid IDR award, joining the Fifth Circuit. Here is where that leaves providers holding awards the insurance company has not paid.
CMS is recertifying the IDR entities that decide No Surprises Act disputes, posting them in weekly lists that stay open for public petitions for five business days. The first list, including Maximus, closed October 22, 2026. Providers who have seen recurring problems with an IDR entity can put them on the record.
The No Surprises Act gives insurers 30 days to pay an IDR award, but it doesn't say how a provider collects when they don't. Two appeals courts now say providers can't sue, the Supreme Court declined to step in, and Congress hasn't acted. Here is where things stand.
The Lower Premiums, Faster Payments Act would replace federal IDR with payment at the QPA for services furnished on or after January 1, 2028. It is a bill, not law. As drafted, earlier services keep their IDR rights.
The 2026 federal IDR operations rule cut the administrative fee from $115 to $15 per party, doubled batch size to 50 items, moved open negotiation into the federal portal and shortened several deadlines. Here is what changed for providers.