Courts
Fifth Circuit strikes "ghost rates" from the QPA, and the government takes the remedy to the Supreme Court
In August the full Fifth Circuit struck down two parts of the federal rules for calculating the qualifying payment amount (QPA), a change commentators expect to push some QPAs up. On October 14 the government asked the Supreme Court to review only the remedy, not the QPA holding itself.
What happened
The qualifying payment amount (QPA) is the insurance company's own calculation of its median in-network rate for a service. It sets the patient's cost sharing, and it is one of the factors an IDR entity weighs when it picks between the two offers.
On August 11, 2026, the full Fifth Circuit, sitting en banc, decided Texas Medical Association v. HHS (No. 23-40605), the case usually called TMA III. The court agreed with the physician and air ambulance plaintiffs that two parts of the federal QPA rules go beyond what the No Surprises Act allows, and it left those parts vacated. The judges split widely: Polsinelli counts four separate opinions from 17 judges, with nine joining the main opinion in full.
On October 14, the Solicitor General asked the Supreme Court to review the case (HHS v. Texas Medical Association, No. 26-491). The petition doesn't defend the QPA rules. It challenges only the remedy.
What the court decided about the QPA
According to summaries from Polsinelli, Troutman Pepper Locke and Akerman, the court ruled on three QPA questions:
- "Ghost rates" are out. Insurers may no longer count contracted rates for services a provider never actually furnishes. These rates often sit at or near zero because nobody ever negotiated them. The court read the statute's wording, rates for services "provided by a provider", to exclude them.
- Bonus and incentive payments can't be excluded wholesale. The 2021 rule let insurers leave out risk-sharing, bonus, incentive and other after-the-fact payment adjustments. The court held that categorical exclusion unlawful.
- Single-case agreements stay out. On this point the government won. One-off agreements still don't count toward the QPA.
Akerman expects dropping ghost rates to raise some QPAs, though not until insurers recalculate under new guidance. Polsinelli adds that the decision doesn't control what an IDR entity picks, and that nothing in it reopens determinations already made.
What the government is asking the Supreme Court
The petition isn't about surprise billing. As the Georgetown O'Neill Institute and SCOTUSblog describe it, the government argues that the Administrative Procedure Act doesn't let courts vacate a rule for everyone. In its view, relief should be limited to the parties who sued. It relies on the Supreme Court's 2025 decision limiting universal injunctions (Trump v. CASA).
What this means for the QPA:
- The QPA holding itself isn't on appeal. The government isn't defending the ghost-rate or incentive-payment provisions.
- If the government wins on the remedy, the rules could be set aside only for the plaintiffs, not for every insurer. Georgetown notes that this would be hard to administer: insurers could need different QPA methods depending on which provider a patient saw.
- Timing. The plaintiffs' response was due November 13, but on October 29 the Court extended the deadline to December 14, 2026, at the government's request. Four justices must vote to hear the case. Georgetown expects that a grant this term would mean a decision in 2027.
Enforcement relief ended October 1
Since 2023, federal regulators have let insurers keep calculating QPAs under the 2021 method while the litigation played out. The most recent extension (FAQ Part 73, April 1, 2026) covered services furnished before October 1, 2026. Gottlieb & Greenspan's October update reports that no further extension has been issued, and we found none.
CMS said on August 13 that the federal IDR process remains operational and that guidance would follow. As of this post, the regulators haven't said how a corrected QPA should be calculated, whether it applies to earlier claims, or how compliance will be checked.
What it means for providers
- The QPA in a new dispute may change. For services furnished on or after October 1, 2026, the insurer's QPA should no longer include ghost rates. Commentators expect some QPAs to rise. How much depends on the specialty, the market and the insurer's network.
- The QPA is still not the answer. The law requires the IDR entity to consider the QPA alongside the other factors the parties submit. A higher QPA can narrow the gap between the offers, but it doesn't decide the outcome.
- Nothing reopens closed disputes. Polsinelli reads the decision as giving no basis to revisit determinations already issued.
- Watch for two things: the regulators' post-decision guidance, and whether the Supreme Court takes the case. A narrower remedy could leave the QPA rules different for different providers.
- Legislation could override the courts. Rep. Pallone's bill would make the QPA methodology unreviewable in court and replace IDR for services from 2028 (our summary). It is a bill, not law.
MD Claims checks the QPA on every claim we take on, and builds each offer on the current rules. See how we file, or read our guide to the No Surprises Act for providers.
MD Claims is not a law firm, and this post is not legal advice.
What law firms are saying
- Akerman: HRx: Caught by Surprise! NSA's QPA Calculation Methodology Given the Boot
- Troutman Pepper Locke: Fifth Circuit Rules En Banc on Key QPA Calculation Disputes Under the No Surprises Act
- Gottlieb & Greenspan: No Surprises Act Update: October 2026
- Sidley (counsel to the physician plaintiffs): For the Sixth Time, Sidley-Represented Physicians Prevail in No Surprises Act Challenge
Sources
- Polsinelli: En Banc Fifth Circuit Rejects Key QPA Rules in TMA III (Aug. 13, 2026)
- Georgetown O'Neill Institute: Trump Administration Asks Supreme Court To Limit Universal Vacatur In No Surprises Act Case (Oct. 20, 2026)
- SCOTUSblog: Department of Health and Human Services v. Texas Medical Association, No. 26-491 (case page)
- SCOTUSblog: Trump administration asks justices to determine courts' ability to vacate federal agency actions (Oct. 16, 2026)
- CMS: No Surprises Act notices, including the TMA III statement of Aug. 13, 2026
- U.S. Department of Labor: FAQs about Consolidated Appropriations Act, 2021 Implementation Part 73 (Apr. 1, 2026)
- Georgetown O'Neill Institute: Health Care Litigation Tracker, No Surprises Act
More news
This is news and commentary, not legal advice. Talk to counsel about your specific situation.