IDR Process
IDR batching changes on November 1: 50-item batches and a shorter cooling-off period
The batching rules in the 2026 IDR operations rule apply to disputes whose open negotiation begins on or after November 1, 2026: up to 50 line items per batch, new grouping rules and a 30-business-day cooling-off period. Most other changes are still waiting on CMS, and the new IDR Gateway takes over the web forms from November 13.
The short version
The first big piece of the 2026 IDR operations rule takes effect on November 1, 2026. Every batching provision in the rule applies to disputes whose open negotiation period begins on or after that date, according to CMS's August 7 implementation timeline. Batches can hold up to 50 line items, the rules for what can be grouped together change, and the cooling-off period after a batched decision drops to 30 business days.
Two dates follow close behind. From November 13, the IDR forms move into the new IDR Gateway, and the old stand-alone web forms stop working after January 15, 2027.
What applies from November 1
The trigger is when open negotiation starts, not when you file. Open negotiation begins when the open negotiation notice is sent, and it runs 30 business days before IDR can be started. So a claim whose negotiation notice went out on October 30 stays under the old batching rules, even if the dispute is filed in December. Disputes under the new rules can't be filed until mid-December at the earliest.
Batches can hold 50 line items. CMS says batched disputes with an open negotiation start date on or after November 1 are limited to 50 dispute line items, up from 25.
New grouping rules. Batched items must involve the same insurer and must have been furnished within the same 30-business-day period. They must also share one of the following: a single patient in a single encounter; different patients with the same or a comparable code; or, for anesthesia, radiology, pathology and laboratory services, codes in the same CPT Category I range. Our summary of the IDR operations final rule covers these in more detail.
A shorter cooling-off period for batches. After a decision on a batched dispute, the party that started it can't bring a new dispute against the same opponent for the same item or service for 30 business days. Before, that wait was 90 calendar days. CMS's October 2 notice says the system will enforce the timing of the next dispute: it can't be started before the cooling-off period ends, or more than 4 business days after it ends.
The old rules keep running alongside the new ones. Per CMS, batched disputes whose open negotiation began before November 1, and all single and bundled disputes, stay on the 90-calendar-day cooling-off period.
What doesn't change yet
Most of the rule's procedural changes are not live. Open negotiation through the federal portal, the new initiation steps, IDR entity selection, the remaining withdrawal provisions and extensions each apply 90 calendar days after CMS announces that the supporting system feature is available. CMS's timeline says it expects to build those features in spring 2027. Until then, those parts of the process work as they do today.
One more date is set: insurers must use the specified remittance codes (CARCs and RARCs) for items and services furnished on or after January 1, 2027, according to the same timeline.
The IDR Gateway: November 13 and January 15
CMS is moving the federal IDR process from single-use web forms to an account-based IDR Gateway. According to CMS's October 14 notice:
- From November 13, 2026, Gateway account holders can submit the Notice of IDR Initiation, the initiation response, the IDR entity selection and offer forms there.
- After January 15, 2027, the old web forms outside the Gateway go away, except the resubmission form.
- Anyone who files disputes, submits IDR forms or represents a party needs an account, which includes identity verification. If a third party files for you, it is that party that needs the account.
What it means for providers
- Expect two sets of rules through the winter. Batches from negotiations that began before November 1 keep the old limits and the 90-day cooling-off period, and single and bundled disputes keep 90 days. Track the open negotiation start date for every claim.
- Bigger batches mean fewer disputes. For practices that bill many similar codes against the same insurer, a 50-item limit can halve the number of separate disputes, and the per-dispute administrative fee with them.
- The cooling-off clock is tighter. The wait after a batched decision is shorter, but the window to file the next dispute afterward is only 4 business days. Miss it and the system won't take the filing.
- Sign up for the Gateway now if you file your own disputes, so the January 15 cutoff doesn't catch you mid-case.
For background on the rest of the rule, see the IDR operations final rule.
MD Claims is not a law firm, and this post is not legal advice.
Filing IDR disputes yourself? MD Claims files and manages federal IDR disputes for providers, including batching and the move to the IDR Gateway, and can advance capital against claims already in arbitration.
What law firms are saying
Sources
More news
This is news and commentary, not legal advice. Talk to counsel about your specific situation.