Courts
Unpaid IDR awards reach the Seventh Circuit after two Illinois losses for providers
Two federal judges in Chicago held this year that providers can't sue to collect unpaid IDR awards. Five appeals are now consolidated in the Seventh Circuit, backed by the AMA. Separately, PHI Health has sued Anthem in at least three states, alleging roughly $30 million in unpaid awards nationwide.
Two Chicago judges, two losses for providers
Two judges on the federal district court in Chicago have now ruled against providers trying to collect IDR awards that Health Care Service Corporation (HCSC), the parent of several Blue Cross Blue Shield plans, did not pay.
- SpecialtyCare v. HCSC (June 2, 2026). A neuromonitoring company and two affiliated physician groups sued over unpaid awards against Blue Cross Blue Shield of New Mexico. Judge Manish Shah dismissed every federal claim with prejudice. In his view, the No Surprises Act creates no private right to sue, the Federal Arbitration Act's confirmation procedure doesn't apply to IDR awards, and an underpayment claim falls outside ERISA. He dismissed the state-law claims without prejudice, so they could be refiled in state court.
- PHI Health v. HCSC (August 5, 2026). An air ambulance company brought claims under the Act, the Federal Arbitration Act, ERISA and Illinois consumer-protection law. Judge Matthew Kennelly granted HCSC's motion to dismiss, and judgment was entered on August 18.
Both providers appealed.
Five appeals, one Seventh Circuit case
The Seventh Circuit has consolidated five appeals against HCSC, led by SpecialtyCare v. HCSC (No. 26-2269). The Seventh Circuit covers Illinois, Indiana and Wisconsin. The providers filed their opening brief on September 9. Their lead argument is pointed: the Act tells insurers they shall pay an award within 30 days, but it gives the federal agencies no tool that actually forces an insurer to pay a provider. If courts can't enforce awards either, the providers argue, "binding" means nothing.
On September 16, two groups filed amicus briefs on the providers' side: the American Medical Association with the Illinois State Medical Society, and the Emergency Department Practice Management Association with an ambulance operators' alliance. HCSC's brief is next. No argument date has been set. Check the Georgetown litigation tracker for the latest filings.
This is the third appeals court to take up the question. The Fifth Circuit (2025) and the Second Circuit (September 2026) both ruled against providers. A Seventh Circuit win for providers would create the circuit split that usually brings the Supreme Court in. Another loss would make three circuits against providers.
PHI Health takes on Anthem in three more courts
PHI Health has also sued Anthem (Elevance Health) in at least three more places:
- Kentucky (filed August 17, 2026): about $2.1 million in awards, according to a press release from PHI's counsel, Wick Phillips.
- Federal court in Missouri: more than a dozen awards totaling about $333,000, according to a Berkowitz Oliver update.
- Federal court in Indiana (filed August 31, 2026): awards tied to Indiana patients, plus interest of more than $1.3 million, according to press reports.
Across these suits, PHI says Anthem has paid late, or not at all, on more than 1,000 awards nationwide. The counts differ by source: Wick Phillips puts it at about $28 million, and press reports say about 1,200 awards and $30 million. Anthem's position, through Elevance, is that it follows the IDR process, which "has clear eligibility requirements that all parties are expected to follow." Kentucky sits in the Sixth Circuit and Missouri in the Eighth, and neither has ruled on award enforcement. Indiana sits in the Seventh, so the consolidated appeal will likely control the Indiana case.
State-law claims aren't filling the gap
When the federal route closes, providers often turn to state law. That isn't working so far either. Becker's reports that on September 17 a New York state trial court dismissed all seven state-law claims that Long Island practices brought against four Anthem companies over 13 unpaid awards worth more than $1.7 million. The claims included unjust enrichment, New York's prompt-pay law and bad faith. The court's reasoning: both the duty to pay and the amount came from the federal IDR process, so state law can't enforce what the Act itself doesn't let providers enforce. Federal judges in Illinois and Delaware haven't reached the question: after throwing out (or recommending throwing out) the federal claims in similar suits against HCSC, Cigna and UMR, they left the state-law claims for state courts.
Regulators are hearing about it too
On October 1, CMS met with the leaders of all 17 certified IDR entities. One of the problems on the agenda was payments that are delayed or never made after an IDR decision. CMS announced no new enforcement step. But unpaid awards now appear on the regulators' own list of what's wrong with the process.
What it means for providers
- Your award is still binding. These cases are about how you collect, not whether the money is owed. The insurance company still has 30 days to pay.
- In Illinois, Indiana and Wisconsin, a federal suit is uphill until the Seventh Circuit rules. Two Chicago judges have already said no. Ask counsel before you build a collection plan around court.
- Don't count on state law as a backup. The New York state court that ruled in September rejected it.
- Watch this appeal. It's the next real chance at a provider-friendly appellate ruling, and the AMA is backing it.
- Track every award. Record the due date, the payment received and the gap. Whatever the courts decide, a clean record of each award is what regulators and courts act on.
For the bigger picture, see where the courts stand on unpaid IDR awards.
MD Claims is not a law firm, and this post is not legal advice. Whether a lawsuit is open to you depends on where you are and on your facts; ask counsel.
Holding awards the insurance company hasn't paid? MD Claims follows every award through to payment, and can advance capital against unpaid IDR awards.
What law firms are saying
- Wick Phillips: Lawsuit Alleges Widespread Elevance Health Nonpayment of Binding Federal Arbitration Awards (press release, Aug. 25, 2026)
- Berkowitz Oliver: Missouri Lawsuit Raises New Questions About Elevance Health's Alleged Nonpayment of Binding No Surprises Act Awards
- Hall Benefits Law: Suit Alleges Anthem Withheld $30 Million in No Surprises Act Awards
Sources
- SpecialtyCare, Inc. v. Health Care Service Corp., No. 1:24-cv-12902 (N.D. Ill. June 2, 2026), memorandum opinion, filed with the notice of appeal
- PHI Health, LLC v. Health Care Service Corp., No. 1:26-cv-02954 (N.D. Ill.), notice of appeal (Aug. 19, 2026)
- Plaintiffs' opening brief, SpecialtyCare v. HCSC, Nos. 26-2269 et al. (7th Cir., filed Sept. 9, 2026)
- American Medical Association and Illinois State Medical Society amicus filing (7th Cir., Sept. 16, 2026)
- Emergency Department Practice Management Association et al. amicus brief (7th Cir., Sept. 16, 2026)
- Georgetown O'Neill Institute, PHI Health LLC v. Health Care Services Corporation (litigation tracker)
- Inside Indiana Business: Health insurer Anthem targeted in lawsuit over air ambulance claims
- Becker's Payer Issues: Elevance wins dismissal of provider lawsuit over $1.7M in unpaid No Surprises awards
- SpecialtyCare v. Cigna Healthcare, No. 24-1378 (D. Del.), report and recommendation
- CMS: CMS convenes certified IDR entity leaders to discuss ways to improve the Federal IDR process (Oct. 1, 2026)
More news
This is news and commentary, not legal advice. Talk to counsel about your specific situation.