IDR Process

The arbitrators are now under scrutiny: CMS, Congress and the press turn to the IDR entities

By MD Claims ·

CMS called in the leaders of all 17 certified IDR entities on October 1, Rep. Pallone has demanded records from six of them, and on October 19 a STAT investigation looked at how much money some of the nonprofit ones are making. Here is what the scrutiny means for disputes you file now.

Three kinds of scrutiny in one month

For most of the No Surprises Act's life, the debate was about providers and insurers. This fall the focus has moved to the certified IDR entities, the private organizations that decide the disputes.

  • CMS (October 1). CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz and officials from Labor and the Treasury met with leaders of all 17 certified IDR entities. According to CMS, they discussed rising costs, delays, growing case volume, ineligible disputes, unclear explanations for decisions, and awards that are paid late or not at all. CMS said the agencies will consider "all available regulatory and operational solutions." It announced no rule. The entities committed to improving their processes.
  • Congress (September 3). Rep. Frank Pallone, the top Democrat on the Energy and Commerce Committee, wrote to six entities: C2C Innovative Solutions, Commence, Dane Street, EdiPhy Advisors, National Medical Reviews and ProPeer Resources. He asked for data on dispute volume, eligibility rulings and defaults. He also asked how arbitrators are trained and paid, whether they use AI tools, and whether they have any financial ties to the parties that file disputes, including private equity. Responses were due September 24. Weeks later, Pallone introduced his bill to end IDR for services after 2027.
  • The press (October 19). A STAT investigation reported on the finances of nonprofit IDR entities. It found that one of them, Michigan-based iMPROve Health, went from losing more than $2 million in 2022 to a profit margin of about 70%, with revenue up 13-fold, as dispute volume surged.

Why it's happening now

The volume is far beyond what anyone planned for. CMS says the federal process has received and closed more than 7 million disputes since April 2022. Pallone's letter cites 2.5 million disputes filed in 2025, against an original estimate of about 17,000 a year. Insurers and employer groups argue that the entities have every reason to let questionable disputes through. Providers answer that they win most cases because insurers' offers are too low. Either way, the entities sit in the middle, and they are the part of the system regulators can change fastest.

What could change

Nothing has changed yet. But the levers are already in place:

  • Recertification. CMS is recertifying entities in weekly batches, and each batch is open to public petitions. See our post on how to petition against an IDR entity's recertification.
  • Deadlines already on the books. The 2026 IDR operations rule put IDR entities on the clock, including a deadline for deciding whether a dispute is eligible.
  • The new IDR Gateway. It replaces the federal portal starting in late 2026. CMS has said it will build new functions into it for disputes whose open negotiation begins on or after November 1, 2026.

The likeliest near-term effect is stricter eligibility review and more detailed written decisions. Both cut both ways for providers: more disputes may be found ineligible, but a win will be harder for an insurer to attack later.

What it means for providers

  • Eligibility has to be right the first time. An entity under scrutiny is less likely to give a borderline dispute the benefit of the doubt. Batching, timing and the open-negotiation record all need to hold up.
  • Your argument has to be one an arbitrator can write down. CMS named "unclear determination rationales" as a problem. Submissions that tie the offer to the statutory factors make that rationale easy to write.
  • The awards you hold aren't affected. Scrutiny of the entities doesn't reopen decided disputes. Collecting them is a separate fight; see where the courts stand on unpaid awards.

MD Claims is not a law firm, and this post is not legal advice.

Want disputes filed so they hold up under closer review? MD Claims files and manages federal IDR disputes from open negotiation through payment.

Sources

More news

This is news and commentary, not legal advice. Talk to counsel about your specific situation.