IDR Process

How to petition CMS against an IDR entity's recertification

By MD Claims · · Updated

CMS is recertifying the IDR entities that decide No Surprises Act disputes, posting them in weekly lists that stay open for public petitions for five business days. The first list, including Maximus, closed October 22, 2026. Providers who have seen recurring problems with an IDR entity can put them on the record.

What's happening

IDR entities, the organizations that decide federal No Surprises Act disputes, are certified for five years (per CMS) and must reapply to keep deciding cases. CMS posts the entities that have met the minimum recertification requirements in lists, and each list opens a short window for anyone to object.

The first list covered October 16 to October 22, 2026, and that window has closed. The five entities on it, per CMS:

  • Maximus Federal Services, Inc.
  • ProPeer Resources, LLC
  • C2C Innovative Solutions, Inc.
  • Medical Evaluators of Texas ASO, LLC
  • Federal Hearings and Appeals Services, LLC

CMS says it will post more entities each week on a rolling basis as it reviews their applications, and each list stays open for petitions for five business days. The current list is on CMS's petition page, linked below. Check it weekly: a window can open and close inside one working week.

Who can petition, and how

Providers, facilities, air ambulance providers, insurers, state regulators and members of the public can all file. A petition goes through the federal IDR petition form. It must name the entity and explain why it shouldn't be recertified, and CMS recommends attaching supporting documents. CMS says petitioners get an email acknowledgment within 10 days.

If a petition shows the entity doesn't meet the Act's requirements, CMS notifies the entity, lets it respond, and then makes the final decision. Under the rules, that review can cover conflicts of interest and whether the entity can decide a high volume of disputes accurately, on time and with rationales that meet the rules, according to CMS's recertification FAQs.

What it means for providers

  • This is a rare chance to be heard on the decision-makers. If your disputes before one of these entities have shown a pattern (eligibility rejections that ignore the record, missed deadlines, decisions that don't address the evidence submitted), a documented petition is the formal place to say so.
  • Evidence beats anecdote. Dispute numbers, dates, the determinations themselves and the submissions they ignored carry weight. A general complaint about outcomes will not.
  • Watch the weekly lists. More entities will be posted over the coming weeks, each with only five business days for petitions. Have the evidence ready before the entity you have concerns about is posted.
  • Disputes in progress are protected. Per CMS's FAQs, an entity whose certification is expiring stops receiving new disputes 90 days before it lapses but must finish the ones already assigned to it.

Recertification sits alongside the oversight changes in the 2026 rule. For those, see our summary of the IDR operations final rule.

MD Claims is not a law firm and this post is not legal advice.

Sources

More news

This is news and commentary, not legal advice. Talk to counsel about your specific situation.